Water. And Doctor Who.
May. 8th, 2006 11:27 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
dangermousieSaw Water, a movie about treatment of widows, and thought it was a powerful, understated, beautiful movie. I thought the entire cast was good, but the person who stood out the most was Serala, the girl who played Chuiya. She was amazing. I also liked the fact that the movie didn't go for the simplistic 'men are evil' paradigm. There are men who take advantage of the situation (all those Brahmin who Kalyani services), there are good men (Narayan and the Priest, who is the one who tells Shakuntala about the new laws allowing widow remarriage), and the vast majority, like Narayan's friend, are indifferent. And of course, it also showcases that in the society women become complicit in their own subjugation: Madhu who runs the ashram is horrible, and witness the widows' indignant reaction to Chuiya's innocent question of 'where is the house of men widows?' And the cinematography was beautiful.
The scenes that especially stood out were:
1. The scene in the rain, with Kalyani and Chuiya playing that frantic hand game (they are both still such children, even Kalyani) intercut with Narayan wandering through streets without an umbrella. It was just a scene full of such joy, in a rather heart-breaking movie.
2. The last frames being just that spent, empty look on Seema Biswas' face (she was beyond amazing). Because Chuiya might have been saved, but there is no way out for her.
3. The scene where Chuiya "comes to play." I admit I was spoiled for large parts of the movie but not for this, and I couldn't bear watch, I had to look through my fingers. Does anyone else think that not only was Narayan's father one of Kalyani's clients, he was specifically one of her clients when she was a child? Just the vibe I got.
4. The look on the elderly widow's face when she finally tastes that laddoo. And the flashback to her wedding as a child.
5. The scene where Narayan and Kalyani meet by that tree. It was beautiful, and fairy tale and romantic.
Also saw Doctor Who's ep, "Father's Day" (I am a billion eps behind everyone else) and it was excellent except I wanted to smack Rose for being a moron for a solid first half of the show. Ugh. Also, is it me, or is this show more Rose-centric than Doctor-centric?
The scenes that especially stood out were:
1. The scene in the rain, with Kalyani and Chuiya playing that frantic hand game (they are both still such children, even Kalyani) intercut with Narayan wandering through streets without an umbrella. It was just a scene full of such joy, in a rather heart-breaking movie.
2. The last frames being just that spent, empty look on Seema Biswas' face (she was beyond amazing). Because Chuiya might have been saved, but there is no way out for her.
3. The scene where Chuiya "comes to play." I admit I was spoiled for large parts of the movie but not for this, and I couldn't bear watch, I had to look through my fingers. Does anyone else think that not only was Narayan's father one of Kalyani's clients, he was specifically one of her clients when she was a child? Just the vibe I got.
4. The look on the elderly widow's face when she finally tastes that laddoo. And the flashback to her wedding as a child.
5. The scene where Narayan and Kalyani meet by that tree. It was beautiful, and fairy tale and romantic.
Also saw Doctor Who's ep, "Father's Day" (I am a billion eps behind everyone else) and it was excellent except I wanted to smack Rose for being a moron for a solid first half of the show. Ugh. Also, is it me, or is this show more Rose-centric than Doctor-centric?
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2006-05-08 03:54 pm (UTC)Is the ending tragic? Will I need to have many tissues?
no subject
Date: 2006-05-08 04:00 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-05-08 04:23 pm (UTC)Also "Father's Day" - well I think they both act like idiots. She's the twit who saves her father and then is all surprised that the Doctor is upset about it. And he's the idiot who thinks it would be a great idea to bring a 19 year old to see her father die. Seriously, that is the dumbest thing anyone has ever agreed to do. I don't think the Doctor really ever bothers to think anything through in any of his incarnations.
Hmmm...I think the show is Rose heavy, but that shifts in some episodes. We certainly see more of her background than any other companion.
no subject
Date: 2006-05-08 04:51 pm (UTC)Yes. When she is all "you are just upset because you are not the most important man in my life" I just want to yell 'doesn't it occur to you he might be pissed because you screwed with the laws of time instead?'
he's the idiot who thinks it would be a great idea to bring a 19 year old to see her father die
ROFL.
no subject
Date: 2006-05-08 06:31 pm (UTC)I just have finished watching "Earth", and what a beautiful, truthful and gut-wrenching movie it is! Rahul Khanna is the love of my life now. Thank you very much , for I got to know about this film ages ago from you comment and posts. It took a while for the DVD to reach me..:) All the rest is still in the queue. It is interesting that I noticed that Bollywood films (I know "Earth is not a Bollywood film) don't seem to be arriving from the Blockbuster queue :(
no subject
Date: 2006-05-08 06:52 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-05-08 07:54 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-05-08 07:55 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2006-05-09 01:19 am (UTC)BTW, do you simply not require sleep in order to get all this viewing time in? because truly, it does boggle my poor feeble mind here (and ever growing netflix queue)
no subject
Date: 2006-05-09 04:06 am (UTC)